Is Apple Watch a Design Flop? That was the conclusion, it seems, of an all-star design panel.

By Clifton Leaf

This story originally appeared on Fortune Magazine

Apple
Apple Watch

In an age when every day dumps a new whizbang product—a me-too smartphone, watch, tablet, fitness tracker, sound system, app—on consumers' laps, there is something critical, something deeply human, being lost: design. Such was the provocative conclusion of an all-star panel of designers gathered at Fortune"s Brainstorm Tech this afternoon.

One of the key challenges, said one speaker after another, is that product-makers misunderstand what design is.

The biggest misconception? "The belief that it's about making things pretty," said Margaret Gould Stewart, Facebook's director of product design.

John Maeda, a former president of the Rhode Island School of Design who is now a design partner at venerable venture capital firm Kleiner Perkins, offered another candidate: "The mistaken belief that we need design for everything."

"It's "design thinking,' countered Gadi Amit, principal designer at the San Francisco-based NewDealDesign. "The mistake is attributing to design a cerebral quality that is not necessarily there and shouldn't be the focal point."

Where there was more accord, surprisingly, was in the group's assessment that the prodigiously hyped Apple Watch is a manifestation of at least some of these misconceptions.

"I'm actually highly disappointed by the Apple Watch," said Amit. "To some degree, Apple missed an opportunity to redefine why the tiny screen is on our wrist at all. I'm an Apple admirer and hoped for an "iPhone moment.' This wasn't it."

"From a marginal perspective, I don't think it simplifies my life," said Tristan Walker, CEO of Walker & Company Brands.

In a broader sense, "the idea of the watch is anachronistic," offered Stewart. "It's transitional. In a few years we're going to look at different devices."

Among the group, Maeda was the kindest—though his was hardly a ringing endorsement: ""It was a good try. Let's see what comes next."

Clifton Leaf is the deputy editor of Fortune Magazine.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Career

What Is 'Task Masking'? Young Workers Retaliate Against Return-to-Office Mandates With a Viral Strategy.

Many professionals value the flexibility of remote work — and they're not reacting well to forced in-office returns.

Growing a Business

Want to Know What Your Customers Really Think? Here's How to Implement a Successful Social Listening Strategy.

Learn how to implement a powerful social listening strategy to track conversations, gain valuable insights and actively engage with your audience to strengthen your brand and boost sales.

Business News

These Are the 'Secrets' to Getting a Deal on a Home (Even in This Real Estate Market), According to Barbara Corcoran

With home prices and mortgage rates still high, even the always-optimistic Barbara Corcoran admits it "feels impossible."

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.

Growing a Business

How to Build Meaningful Connections in the Digital Networking Era

In a world of digital noise and curated personas, authenticity fosters a deeper, more lasting connection. Networking for today's world (and tomorrow's) will require a balance of technology and human touch.

Money & Finance

He's Helping College Athletes Navigate a Multi-Billion-Dollar Industry — But His Top Money Tip Can Help Anybody Grow Substantial Wealth

Michael Haddix Jr. saw his father, a former NFL player, struggle with money management after retirement. Now, he wants student-athletes to secure their financial futures.