Tell Us: Is Intellectual Property Even Property at All? Businesses spend a lot of time and money fretting over patent issues, but perhaps the concept of intellectual property as a whole needs to be re-examined.

By Ray Hennessey Edited by Dan Bova

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

intellectual-property.legalhelp.org

Is intellectual property even property at all?

Businesses fret over IP issues all the time. On the one hand, they covetously protect what ideas they believe are theirs alone, making sure to use the courts to protect the exclusivity of whatever products grow from those thoughts. On the other hand, these same companies often find themselves on the receiving end of lawsuits from others who claim their ideas were not as original as they thought. It's worse that there are also patent trolls who have made a business out of threatening lawsuits over intellectual property.

Related: Angry Business Owner Wages War on 'Troll'

But are these patent fights even valid? Attorney David D'Amato argues that they are not -- that, in fact, intellectual property is not true property at all. Ideas are evolutionary. In short, he says, endowing ideas with rights is ridiculous and impossible.

"Any attempt to neatly partition the contributions made by one mind or another, through all the ages of invention and scientific discovery, is vain and fruitless to the point of inanity," he writes. "Inventions constantly both absorb and propagate one another, plagiarizing, consuming and collaborating to create still newer inventions. To source any idea whatsoever to a particular individual or group is to assume that we know far more than we ever could about the full picture of the idea's germination and evolution."

By assigning rights to intellectual property, argues D'Amato, "is a millstone around the neck of innovation and technological progress, a political mechanism for stifling both in favor of bare monopoly."

Businesses spend a lot on intellectual property. Even filing for a patent for a simple, basic ideas will cost the inventor a minimum of $5,000, and usually more. Then there is the cost of defending and protecting patents and IP.

Is it worth it? Should we treat intellectual property as property at all?

Tell us your opinion.

Ray Hennessey

Former Editorial Director at Entrepreneur Media

Ray Hennessey is the former editorial director of Entrepreneur.

Want to be an Entrepreneur Leadership Network contributor? Apply now to join.

Editor's Pick

Business News

What the FTC's 'Click-to-Cancel' Rule Means for Merchants

Subscriptions are easy to start but often difficult to cancel, leading frustrated consumers to seek chargebacks due to confusing cancellation policies. The FTC's new "click-to-cancel" rule mandates that cancellation must be as straightforward as sign-up, potentially reducing chargebacks and improving customer satisfaction.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.

Business News

Zillow Predicts These 10 Places Will Have the Hottest Housing Markets in 2025

Zillow predicted that the hottest housing market of 2025 will be Buffalo, New York. Here's why.

Business Solutions

Say Hello to the PDF Multi-Tool You Didn't Know You Needed

Get lifetime access to UPDF for just $47.99—the best price online right now.

Business Culture

It's Time to Rewrite Your Company's Values — Here's How

Most companies' values are forgotten or disconnected from daily operations. By rethinking and co-creating values with your team, you can transform them into actionable tools that align behavior, build trust and drive performance.

Science & Technology

5 AI Books Top Entrepreneurs Are Reading in a Rush for 2025

Entrepreneurs must embrace AI or risk falling behind. Discover 2025's top 5 AI books to gain a competitive edge, featuring insights from "The Wolf is at the Door" and a free AI Success Kit.