How Important is the Founder's Educational Pedigree? Good educational pedigree often results in numerous downstream benefits in the start-up ecosystem

By Devang Mehta

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.

You're reading Entrepreneur India, an international franchise of Entrepreneur Media.

Shutterstock

I often get asked, how important is the founder's educational pedigree when judging the overall appeal of a start-up's team? It's an important question and while individual opinions vary, I've seen a general convergence amongst the VC community on this issue.

I believe that education matters more when the founding team is young (let's say average age 25 or less) for the simple reason that a lot of what they have achieved in life is at academic institutions. Success in academia is by no means a guarantee of future success, but it is a good proxy of the ability of the team to produce great products, especially in knowledge-driven industries like high tech. I believe academic success is also a good proxy of the ability to put in long, disciplined hours towards achieving ambitious goals.

An interesting spin on this revolves around the advent of acqui-hiring -- a trend which is beginning to shape (albeit a very smart part) of M&A in India. The philosophy is simple - all other things equal - a young team of engineers from reputable institutions is more likely to get acqui-hired than a similar team from less prominent institutions. A good example of where academic success actually translates into success in the business world. Again, with the caveat, that this is a very small part of M&A activity - so just don't start a company if you are from IIT/MIT/Stanford/CMU in hopes of a payout from the start-up world. Nonetheless, the theory stands - acqu-hiring happens when the knowledge and know-how is extremely valuable to the acquirer -- and this raw technical horsepower is better honed at reputable technological institutions.

As the median age of the starting team gets higher, say closer to the 30's then academic qualifications get eclipsed, to a great extent, by success in the business world and other 'real-world' experiences. So, if one is comparing two founders - one from IIT (just an example of a good University) and the other from University B, and the latter has had a better career path, post-graduation, worked in an entrepreneurially minded company, then the scales are balanced or even tilted slightly in favor of the person from University B.

Other 'Perks' of Good Educational Pedigree

Good educational pedigree often results in numerous downstream benefits in the start-up ecosystem. Most of these revolve around the kinds of people that one can attract to the ecosystem - investors, employees, interns, business development partners, and more.

The central theme, obviously, being the fact that the strong alumni relationships that exist at these institutions. Both in terms of sheer size but also (and this is something I notice), is a sense of school pride that arises from graduating from august colleges. Founders from these colleges, especially the more outgoing ones, are often able to build a good aura around the companies they build - and this tremendously helps in attracting the right team, investors, partners, media attention, and more. This acts as a source of comfort for early-stage investors like us - to know that the founding team has the wherewithal and the resourcefulness to bring together the right set of actors at appropriate phases in the start-up's evolutions. An ability that most will agree is the very difference between success and failure in the early stage industry.

So, Why Not Invest Just in Ivy League Graduates?

Lest you be numbed by what seems to be a continuous endorsement of top-rated academic institutions, I want to remind you - founding team pedigree is just one aspect of Team appeal - and Team is just one aspect of the overall appeal of a start-up. Many staggeringly successful companies have been founded and built by entrepreneurs that have actually dropped out of college. In many other cases, entrepreneurs from less-than-stellar colleges have outperformed peers by building better products, superior marketing strategies, sheer execution finesse and resourcefulness in attracting and charming stakeholders in the ecosystem.

There is also a dark side in investing in 'Ivy leaguers' - a sense of entitlement that comes from the academic pedigree - and something which translates directly into demands for higher valuations and other start-up-friendly terms. I've seen situations where investors, mesmerized by educational pedigree, sign off on significantly unfavorable terms than what the situation normally mandates. Clearly a case of misplaced enthusiasm and irrational understanding of a dynamic that should be used to differentiate between teams in marginal situations (all other things being equal). And not, to be the sole deciding factor in deciding which start-up to invest in.

What does all this mean for aspiring founders? If you've made it to a reputed institution, make the best of it! Build strong networks within the student community - these will be of tremendous value to you throughout your entrepreneurial journey. And if you did not make it to a top-rated school , there are plentiful opportunities to realize your entrepreneurial goals - go ahead and hone your skills and serendipitous moments will come by!

Devang Mehta

Partner, Anthill Ventures

Devang Mehta is a Partner at Anthill Ventures. He is responsible for various activities in the Fund's operations including structuring, fund marketing, devising fund strategy, Investments and advising portfolio companies on growth strategies. Before joining, Anthill, Devang has made angel investments in, and acted as a strategic adviser to, numerous startups in the Food Tech, IoT, FinTech, Healthcare and other Technology verticals.

Prior to his activities in the investing ecosystem, Devang has more than 2 decades of experience in operational areas at early stage companies in various capacities: Marketing, Corporate Strategy, Sales, Product Management, and Software Development. He has played pivotal roles in commercializing Enterprise products and helping them achieve operational profitability.

Devang has degrees in Computer Science and Engineering and an MBA from Carnegie Mellon University's Tepper School of Business with a concentration in Entrepreneurship and Venture Finance.  A Certified Toastmaster, he enjoys Chess, Travel, Sports and Economics.

Business News

JPMorgan Shuts Down Internal Message Board Comments After Employees React to Return-to-Office Mandate

Employees were given the option to leave comments about the RTO mandate with their first and last names on display — and they did not hold back.

Business Ideas

70 Small Business Ideas to Start in 2025

We put together a list of the best, most profitable small business ideas for entrepreneurs to pursue in 2025.

News and Trends

India has the Potential to Host over 620 New Large GCCs by 2030: ANSR

The BFSI sector dominates GCCs in India, followed by Manufacturing and Retail/CPG. There is also a strong focus on digital technologies, with 85 per cent of GCCs engaged in digital commerce initiatives.

News and Trends

Ecozen Secures Over USD 23 Mn Debt Funding to Expand Climate-Smart Solutions

This round of investment will be directed toward scaling Ecozen's flagship solutions, including Ecotron, Ecofrost, and advanced motor control systems.

News and Trends

D2C Skincare Brand Foxtale Raised USD 30 Mn Series C Funding

Last year, the Mumbai-based brand raised USD 18 million (around INR 150 crore) in its Series B funding round, led by Panthera Growth Partners from Singapore.

News and Trends

RP Tech to Acquire 70% Stake in Satcom Infotech to Expand Cybersecurity Portfolio

Satcom Infotech will leverage RP Tech's extensive financial resources and robust nationwide distribution network to enhance service delivery and scale operations. Meanwhile, RP Tech will integrate Satcom's expertise in cybersecurity into its offerings, aiming to introduce new brands and forge impactful industry partnerships.